Saturday, December 6, 2008
Public Disclosure Commission files complaint against Realtors, Rossi, McKenna and various Realtor committees
Rippie alleges that the Realtors did not report $415,000 of political advertising expenditures against Governor Christine Gregoire. The complaint also alleges that the Realtors provided over limit in-kind expenditures to Rossi and McKenna for $498,000 and $29,000. Additionally, she alleges that Rossi and McKenna violated the law by coordinating fundraising with the Realtors.
There was a previous settlement with the Realtors in September, based on a complaint filed by Professor Todd Donovan, of Bellingham, in November of 2007, in which the Realtors were assessed a $130,000 fine for almost a million dollars of illegal expenditures between 2004 and 2007. The PDC suspended part of the fine, based on the Realtor's promise that it would follow all applicable campaign laws through 2011. The Realtors managed to comply with the stipulated agreement for all of one month. http://www.pdc.wa.gov/archive/commissionmeetings/meetingshearings/pdfs/2008/08103.Order.pdf
Sadly, it appears that the PDC lacks the regulatory teeth it needs to stop flagrant abuse of campaign finance and reporting laws. It has become easier for PACs and candidates to pay a series of small fines than comply with campaign finance laws. After all, who actually believes that a $130,000 fine is a financial deterrent to an organization that spends over $4 million dollars on one campaign?
Goldy at Horsesass.org declared it's time for someone "to go to jail for this kind of blatantly illegal electioneering." I agree. The only way to put an end to the flagrant abuse of campaign finance laws is to pass laws that will deter this kind of behavior in the future. (It's impossible to eradicate illegal behavior - but we can significantly reduce violations with increased fines and the threat of criminal prosecution or removing violators from office).
In 1972, the voters of the state of Washington passed an initiative requiring candidates to adhere to strict campaign reporting guidelines.
Over the last 30 years, the state of Washington has been recognized for its commitment to transparency and open campaign reporting. For a number of years, candidates and PACs mostly complied with the law. But in the last five years, we have witnessed a number of cases where PACs and candidates are hiding large monetary contributions from the voters until after the election.
Today, voters and the media attack whistle blowers for filing complaints to publicly expose campaign violations. Both voters and journalists are quick to question the complainant's motivations for filing the complaint, but appear to have little interest in the validity of the complaint itself.
Candidates who have been found guilty of violating the law do not feel that they owe the voters or even the complainant an apology when they are found guilty. Instead, they accuse the individuals who filed the complaint of having questionable motivations.
And, sadly, the voters appear to have bought into the notion that it is ok to break election laws to get into office.
If you value clean elections, call your state legislator and tell them to put some teeth back into campaign finance laws. We need larger fines, jail time for flagrant violators and rules that allow the PDC to remove flagrant campaign law violators from public office.
Perhaps the time is ripe for the legislature to consider public financing of political campaigns.
Horsesass.org article: http://www.horsesass.org/?p=10778
PDC Report of Investigation of first complaint against Realtors: http://www.pdc.wa.gov/archive/commissionmeetings/meetingshearings/pdfs/2008/08103.ROI.pdf
Thursday, October 2, 2008
How to vilify whistle blowers in three articles or less
It's that time of year again -- the month when individuals and organizations begin reviewing PDC reports to identify alleged campaign violations. (Not that we haven't had our fair share of complaints already).After last year's media circus, I thought it would be fun to develop a grading system to fact check media articles and candidate statements.
When possible, Latte Republic will apply the following standard in fact-checking the claims of a journalist, political candidate, political advertising or interest group.
It’s called the "Pinocchio Test" and is based on a similar grading system used by the Washington Post.
Here's how it works:
“One Pinocchio” – statements contain some shading of the facts or selective telling of the truth. Statements contain some omissions and exaggerations, but no outright falsehoods.
“Two Pinocchios” – statements contain significant omissions and/or exaggerations; some factual error may be involved but not necessarily. A politician or journalist can create a false, misleading impression by playing with words and using legalistic language that means little to ordinary people.
“Three Pinocchios” – statement includes significant factual error and/or obvious contradictions.
“Four Pinocchios” – Whoppers
The Geppetto checkmark – identifies statements and claims that contain "the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth" certified by the puppet maker himself.
Why am I covering this issue AGAIN?
Call me old fashioned, but I actually believe that honesty in reporting is an admirable characteristic!
Nor was I ever given the opportunity by Taylor or Bonner to publicly respond to Taylor, Bonner or Pike's accusations last October. (Latte Republic was not born until Dec. 30th of 2007).
Now that we have a grading system, let’s have some fun with one or two of Sam Taylor’s articles/posts regarding Dan Pike's 2007 PDC campaign finance violations. After all, Sam Taylor NEVER hesitates to have fun at my expense!
First, readers should review Sam Taylor’s first article dated, October 20, 2007, when he questions the motivations of the two individuals who filed campaign related complaints regarding alleged campaign finance violations.
(I believe this article sets the stage for all of Taylor's accusations of "wrong doing" from this point on).
Here’s an excerpt for your review and the link to the full article.
Saturday, Oct. 20, 2007
Complaints filed against candidates
Motivations for grievances are questioned
SAM TAYLOR
BELLINGHAM— Two supporters of mayoral candidate Dan McShane have filed complaints with both state and federal officials regarding the campaign contributions of his opponent.
Candidate Dan Pike is calling the complaints, which were filed right around the time ballots were sent to voters, smear tactics by McShane’s camp. (Four Pinocchios for Pike). Fact: I have filed an occasional PDC complaint against other candidates/organizations in past years. Taylor knew this -- he spoke with one of my former professors from Western (the one who filed the FEC Complaint) before he called me. Smear tactics? The PDC will not accept a complaint against a candidate unless they are provided with credible evidence that a violation may have occurred.
“Frankly, what’s going on here is that the other camp does not care whether or not there is any validity, they want an article to say there’s issues,” Pike said. (Four Pinocchios for Pike). Fact: Thanks to Taylor, Candidate Pike is now "officially" the victim of a horrible plot to defame his character -- and I'm the evil person who is attacking him -- all 120 pounds of me). This is one of Taylor's favorite reoccuring themes. Elisabeth Britt - Pike hater. Complainants are required by law to sign an oath swearing that the complaint is based on the truth - not fabrication. Complainants are required to provide factual documentation of the errors/violations at filing. What did I really want? I wanted the public to know that Pike had violated campaign finance reporting laws. Why do I think this is important? Candidates should be able to demonstrate that they have respect for the laws of this state before they are elected to public office.
http://www.bellinghamherald.com/elections/story/211387.html
Just for the fun of it, let's do another post!
10/31/07 -- 02:15:47 pm,
by Sam Taylor ,
433 words
Categories: Best of Locals
*BREAKING* Pike cleared by PDC
The Washington state Public Disclosure Commission has already cleared Bellingham mayoral candidate Dan Pike of a complaint regarding his campaign contributions that was filed by supporters of his opponent. (Four Pinocchios for Taylor) Fact: PDC Investigation was not complete -- in fact, it had not even begun).
The complaint, filed by McShane donor and Washington Conservation Voters member (two Pinocchios for Taylor) Elisabeth Britt, is considered unfounded, (four Pinocchios for Taylor) according to an e-mail sent by Randy Unruh, a PDC political finance specialist to Pike’s campaign treasurer, Ken Bronstein. Unruh told the campaign that he was preparing a “will not investigate memo now.” Fact: I was not a member of Conservation Voters, as pointed out repeatedly by Ann Russell, past president of Conservation Voters on comment pages in the Herald. 2) The PDC Commission had yet to make a determination regarding the complaint against Pike.
“No further action will be taken,” he said in the e-mail. (Four Pinocchios for Taylor and Unruh) Fact: Further action was taken - the PDC Commission - not Randy Unruh, decides if a formal investigation will be opened or not).
*Update: 3:01 p.m. -
I just spoke with Lori Anderson, PDC spokeswoman and she’s working on getting me more information on this. She wanted to make it clear that the dismissal of the complaint will not be “official” until the commission meets, reads the financial specialist’s “will not investigate” memo, and sends a note to the Pike campaign and the person who filed the complaint, Elisabeth Britt. (Geppetto’s checkmark for Anderson) I also have asked Anderson to found out if this is regarding every charge (I think around 57?) (60) filed against Pike and not just the issues with the fundraisers.
Britt had complained that Pike did not report contributions or payments for three political fundraisers that she was concerned were funded by developers. She was also concerned that Pike’s campaign finance reports had been amended so many times that they would be confusing to the public and people wouldn’t be able to figure out what money was coming from where. (One Pinocchio for Taylor). Fact: over simplification -- there is more substance to the complaint than Taylor is disclosing.
The rest of the article can be read here: http://blogs.bellinghamherald.com/index.php?blog=12&title=breaking_pike_cleared_by_pdc&more=1&c=1&tb=1&pb=1
Let's move on to the next article – Please note that an official letter had just been issued by the PDC stating a formal investigation had been opened against the Pike Campaign to examine alleged campaign finance violations.
Mr. Taylor and KGMI were sent copies of the official PDC letter -- and Sam Taylor is still claiming that the investigation is over (as was Brett Bonner on KGMI). Here is an excerpt from the letter dated and received from the PDC on November 1, 2007. Meanwhile, how many ballots have been cast?
From Phil Stutzman, Director of Compliance, PDC, dated November 1, 2007.
Dear Ms. Britt
“This is to acknowledge receipt of your complaint received October 22, 2007 and supplemented on October 25, 2007, alleging violations of RCW 42.17.040, 080. and .090. by the 2007 Dan Pike campaign. The complaint alleges that Mr. Pike failed to file timely and accurate reports of contributions and expenditures. It also alleges that he registered as a candidate one month late, and that he failed to include sponsor identification on a post card distributed at a Democratic Party function on December 8, 2006.
The PDC will investigate these allegations. After our investigation is complete, we will notify you of the results. All laws and rules cited in this letter can be found on our website under www.pdc.gov. ….
Now, check out Sam Taylor’s article/post dated November 2nd, 2007.
Nov, 2, 2007
ELECTIONS
Pike told investigation into funds is over (Four Pinocchios for Taylor and Pike) Fact: the investigation is just beginning.
Public Disclosure Commission mix-up prolongs process
SAM TAYLOR
BELLINGHAM — Two workers at the Public Disclosure Commission have said no further investigation will be conducted regarding a campaign finance complaint against Bellingham mayoral candidate Dan Pike. (Four Pinocchios for Taylor). Fact: Neither staff member quoted has the legal authority to dismiss a complaint under statute; and, an official letter opening a formal investigation had been sent to the complainant and the candidate.
But shortly after the information about Pike’s campaign being cleared became public, PDC staff changed their minds Thursday.
Randy Unruh, a PDC political finance specialist, had already cleared Pike of the complaint and sent an e-mail to Pike’s campaign treasurer, Ken Bronstein, saying so. Pike forwarded the e-mail to media. (Four Pinocchios for Taylor) Fact: Randy Unruh does not have the legal authority under RCW to dismiss a complaint on his own. Only the PDC Commission can do that. Unruh is a PDC staff member, not a commissioner.
But because that e-mail was sent to Pike, the investigation will continue and a letter to Elisabeth Britt, a Dan McShane supporter who filed the complaint, will not be sent as originally planned, said Lori Anderson, PDC spokeswoman. (Four Pinocchios for Anderson and Taylor) Fact: The PDC opened a formal investigation to investigate alleged violations in the complaint -- not because of Unruh's leaked e-mail).
She said the change was not because of reaction from McShane supporters who contacted her office to find out if news reports were true about Pike being cleared.
“It’s in response to a candidate informed of some internal communication that should have never been released outside of this office,” she said. (Three Pinocchios for Anderson) Fact: I agree, the Unruh e-mail should never have been released outside the PDC office --but, despite the fact that it was released, the PDC Commission determined that a formal investigation was warranted, because the complainant (me) had identified multiple alleged campaign finance violations in the Pike campaign filings). There is no provision in statute for the PDC opening an investigation because a candidate leaked an internal communication to garner public sympathy and win an election.
Britt had complained that Pike did not report contributions or payments for three political fundraisers that she was concerned were funded by developers. She was also concerned that Pike’s campaign finance reports had been amended so many times that people wouldn’t be able to figure out what money was coming from where. (One Pinocchio for Taylor). Fact: there is much more to my complaint than what Taylor outlines here.
Pike said that the events had not been reported because at the time his campaign had not received bills for the events to pay for them. He acknowledged that his reports were a mess previously but said his treasurer had worked hard trying to make sure that the PDC had all of the correct information.
Anderson had said Wednesday that the case was basically closed on the investigation, information she received from the PDC’s director of enforcement. (Three Pinocchios for Anderson and Taylor). Fact: the complaint was still being investigated -- the agency had not made a decision regarding the complaint and no letters had been sent out to the candidate or the complainant.
“We looked into some of the allegations. They were really minimal reporting errors,” Anderson said Wednesday. “We asked them to fix them and they did.” (Two Pinocchios) Fact: Randy Unruh had informed Pike that he needed to fix a long list of errors very early in the campaign. In fact, he warned Pike that "you are in a high profile campaign" if you do not fix these errors, someone will come along and file a complaint." Meanwhile, a number of other errors were not corrected). The PDC eventually levied the maximum fine against Pike ($500) for a first complaint, with $250 suspended if he does not violate RCW 42.17 again during the next four years.
Anderson had said no other action would be taken regarding the complaint and the letter would be sent to Britt. (Two Pinocchios) Fact: yada, yada, yada - inaccurate statement -- the commission had yet to render a decision on the complaint.
Told about the changes in the investigation, Pike said he was more concerned about the fate of the PDC employee, whom he felt was doing his job. He said it was unfortunate that the PDC didn’t make clear that there were issues still to be resolved rather than acting like the investigation was over Wednesday. (One Pinocchio for Pike) Fact: How nice! The complaintant, Elisabeth Britt, can go to hell in a hand basket - pike could have cared less what happens to me, as demonstrated by his personal attacks against me in the media. I think the attitude that Pike expressed goes something like this, "so what if she told the truth and I smeared her?" I got what I wanted -- (thousands and thousands of votes).
What I would hope for the PDC is for them to say that we’re sorry that there was a mistake, because we now have to go to this extra degree, which is perfectly fine,” Pike said. (Four Pinocchios for Pike). Fact: yes indeed, Pike got thousands of votes based on inaccurate, if not down right misleading media reporting because he leaked an internal PDC e-mail to the media, representing that a decision had been made, before a decision had actually been made by the Agency.
Britt did not return a phone seeking call comment but said she was working on a written response. After everything Taylor has written, Why on earth would I respond to Taylor after the way he covered this story?
http://www.bellinghamherald.com/102/v-print/story/222827.html
For those readers who are not familiar with the formal results of the PDC investigations and hearings.
Results of Public Disclosure Investigation and Hearings: http://www.pdc.wa.gov/archive/compliance/results/pdf/2008/ResultsOfMay232008BriefEnforcementHearings.pdfPublic
Public Disclosure Commission Findings: On May 23, 2008, the PDC found that the Terrill Bornemann campaign, PDC Case No: 08-086, violated RCW 42.17.060 on numerous occasions by failing to timely deposit monetary contributions received by the campaign within five business days of receipt as required by statute. The Bornemann campaign failed to timely deposit $10,111 in monetary contributions received during the election cycle within five business days of receipt, which represented 57.6 % of the total monetary contributions received by the campaign.
Mr. Bornemann was fined $250, with $125 suspended on the condition that no additional violations of RCW 42.17 take place over the next four years.
On the same day, for PDC Case No: 08-113, the Presiding officer found that Dan Pike violated 1) RCW 42.17.040 on one occasion by failing to timely file a Candidate Registration statement (PDC form C-1); 2) RCW 42.17.080 and .090 on multiple occasions by failing to timely file Monetary Contribution Reports (PDC Form C-3) and Summary Contribution and Expenditure Reports (PDC Form C-4): and 3) RCW 42.17.130 on multiple occasions by using his office computer at the Skagit Council of Governments to send campaign related e-mails that assisted his campaign for Bellingham Mayor.
The Presiding officer dismissed the allegations against Mr. Pike regarding the failure to 1) timely deposit campaign contributions: 2) list the purpose or description for campaign expenditures: 3) attribute a loan received in March of 2007 for the primary election; and, 4) list the occupation and employer for contributors.
Mr. Pike was fined the maximum penalty for a first offense, $500, with $250 suspended as long as no additional violations of RCW 42.17 take place during the next four years. http://www.pdc.wa.gov/archive/compliance/results/pdf/2008/ResultsOfMay232008BriefEnforcementHearings.pdf
Now, wasn't that fun?
* For the record, I do respect Sam Taylor's loyalty and devotion to his friend Dan Pike. Friendship is a precious gift and we are fortunate when we have people who genuinely care about us.
But I do not believe that it is appropriate to distort the news in order to help someone win a campaign. Both Taylor and Bonner indulged in behavior that in my opinion, is ethically unsound.
Washington State, via our public disclosure laws, provides citizens with the legal right to file alleged public disclosure complaints BEFORE AN ELECTION TAKES PLACE.
WA sunshine laws do not limit a citizen's ability to file a campaign finance complaint based on party affiliation, political ideology or because they are supporting a particular candidate's opponent. In fact, the law provides citizens with a process to assist them with filing a complaint.
Complaintants are required by law to provide documented facts to support their complaints at the time of filing.
The Hatch Act complaint is next. It promises to be a dilly!
Webster's Revised Unabridged Dictionary - Cite This Source - Share ThisVilifyVil"i*fy\, v. t. [imp. & p. p. Vilified; p. pr. & vb. n. Vilifying.] [L. vilis vile + -fly; cf. L. vilificare to esteem of little value.]
1. To make vile; to debase; to degrade; to disgrace. [R.]
When themselves they vilified. To serve ungoverned appetite. --Milton.
2. To degrade or debase by report; to defame; to traduce; to calumniate. --I. Taylor.
Many passions dispose us to depress and vilify the merit of one rising in the esteem of mankind. --Addison.
3. To treat as vile; to despise. [Obs.]
I do vilify your censure. --Beau. & Fl.
Realtor's Stipulated Agreement with PDC
The Commission accepted a stipulated agreement in which the Realtors Quality of Life PAC (RQL-PAC) admitted violating campaign disclosure laws in 2004, 2005, 2006, and 2007 by not reporting expenditures, filing late reports, and filing incomplete reports on multiple occasions. RQL-PAC agreed to a penalty of $130,000. Of that amount, $50,000 is suspended provided that RQL-PAC and any successor political committees are not found in violation of campaign disclosure laws through 2011 and that internal controls are established to prevent future reporting errors. An associated allegation that Dan Pike, a 2007 candidate for Mayor of the City of Bellingham, failed to report an in-kind contribution of political advertising from RQL-PAC was dismissed.
The Commission agreed to report to the Attorney General that the Washington State Republican Party has apparently violated the law that restricts how a political party may use its exempt funds. State law allows a political party to accept unlimited contributions into an exempt account, but those funds can only be used for a finite list of activities. The Commission believes there is evidence that the WSRP used its exempt funds to pay for three candidate mailings, an apparent violation of what the law allows.
Legislation/Rulemaking
2009 agency-request legislation regarding false political advertising was approved.
The Commission approved proposed language for:
· new WAC 390-05-222, Domestic Partner - definition
· amended WAC 390-17-305, Personal Funds of a Candidate,
· amended WAC 390-16-207, In-kind contributions – Explanation and reporting,
· amended WAC 390-20-110 Forms for lobbyist employers, and
· amended WAC 390-20-120 Forms for report of legislative activity by public agencies.
A public hearing will be held on December 4, 2008 for possible permanent adoption.
Reporting Modifications
The Commission denied a Personal Financial Affairs reporting modification request by Marlyn E. Jensen, a 2008 candidate for State Representative, to exempt her from disclosing real estate that she owns and the real estate held by her limited liability corporations.
The Commission approved a Personal Financial Affairs reporting modification request for Norman Gutzwiler, Chelan County PUD commissioner, from disclosing the reportable business and governmental customers of two entities for which he serves as a board member: the National Cherry Growers & Industries Foundation and the Washington State Fruit Commission.
Scott Lancaster, Orcas Island School District board member, requested and received a renewal of his Personal Financial Affairs Statement reporting modification.
The Commission meeting materials can be found at www.pdc.wa.gov under Commission Meetings. For additional information concerning these issues contact Lori Anderson, Communications & Training Officer, at (360) 664-2737, toll free 1-877-601-2828 or e-mail at landerson@pdc.wa.gov.
Wednesday, September 24, 2008
Business PAC spending offers clues
I would have loved to have covered this story myself, but my reputation and credibility have been trashed by folks like Sam Taylor, over at the Bellingham Herald and his good friend and blogging buddy, (former Bellingham Herald Community Editorial Board member), Greg Kirsch, (who loves to do his hatchet work anonymously on blogs and on the Herald's electronic comment pages).
Both Taylor and Kirsch are long time supporters of Mayor Dan Pike, a candidate that has been the subject of a number of public disclosure investigations at both the state and federal level.
The Realtor complaint was the second complaint filed against Mr. Pike. Two federal complaints are still under investigation.
According to Tim Johnson, Editor of the Cascadia Weekly, http://www.cascadiaweekly.com/pdfs/issues/200839.pdf, Mayor Pike was recently ordered by the PDC to report $19,038.00 for in-kind contributions he received from the Realtor's Quality of Life PAC during the last two weeks of the 2007 election.
I hope Sam Crawford received the same request in regards to his previously unreported contributions of $12,875. By law, (RCW 42.17) voters have a right to know all sources of a candidate's contributions before the election.
Thanks, Joel, (and Tim Johnson) for taking the time to educate the public regarding the importance of campaign finance laws!
Here's Joel's article -- normally I only print excerpts and provide links to articles, but today, (forgive me Joel), I have to post the entire article. The link to the original article is posted below. (I highlighted the sections that are in bold).
"IN ITS SECOND sharply critical investigative report in three weeks, the Public Disclosure Commission staff found that a big-spending business political action committee flagrantly violated state law.
The commission will take up, at its Thursday meeting, how the Realtors Quality of Life PAC spent $46,650 on seven mailers supporting Whatcom County candidates in the closing days of the 2007 campaign and shelled out $10,000 for a TV ad.
The watchdog agency has, if it chooses, found a strategic time to bare its teeth.
The Realtors Quality of Life PAC is currently sitting on a $708,000 war chest.
The Washington Association of Realtors' legislative committee wants to pour $500,000 into "issues advertising" to "educate voters" in the next month.
"All expenditures under this motion must not advocate the election or defeat of a candidate for public office to be consistent with (federal and state) regulations," says the panel's memo.
Ignore the fanny-covering language. The real purpose of the "education" campaign would be to defeat Gov. Chris Gregoire.
Other people are engaged in similar "education."
Just last Friday, Attorney General Rob McKenna filed civil complaints against the Building Industry Association of Washington and the Master Builders of King and Snohomish Counties.
The complaints followed findings by the PDC staff of "apparent multiple violations" of finance law in funneling money to their anti-Gregoire campaign.
Investigations of builders and Realtors should not be dismissed as political junkie stuff.
Nor should the public believe the customary claims -- of those caught -- that violations are "bookkeeping errors." Guys in $2,000 suits have a curious way of channeling Pinocchio.
A lot of money is in them thar books.
As the commission notes, the Realtors' PAC spent $339,769 for "independent" expenditures in the 2004 cycle, $38,386 in 2005 local elections, $359,940 "independently" in 2006, and made $105,000 in "independent expenditures" (out of total spending of $230,808) in local elections last year.
Big bucks are a clue to officeholders' alliances, growth management votes, and -- if not of politicians being bought -- at least who's being rented.
"Follow the money and the issues the money is chasing," former U.S. Rep. Jolene Unsoeld said in receiving an award last week from the Coalition for Open Government.
If you get to know who really pays for the "hit" pieces in your mailbox, it can be an important factor in how you vote.
In Whatcom County, the disclosure commission found, the Realtors Quality of Life PAC "did not identify the candidates benefitting from the in-kind expenditures and did not provide the required itemization of costs attributable to each mailer."
The final itemization of expenditures was provided 156 days late, on April 3, 2008.
The last day for making unlimited giving to local candidates for the 2007 general election was Oct. 15, 2007. After that, money and in-kind giving was limited to $5,000 in the aggregate.
"The mailings were delivered to the public between Oct. 29 and Nov. 2, 2007. The Washington Realtors Quality of Life did not cancel or reduce the size of the mailings to ensure that the value of the in-kind contributions ... was limited to $5,000," the commission staff reported.
Take an electronic trip to the Public Disclosure Commission's much-improved Web site. Good-government groups are straightforward in where the money has come from, and where it went.
With business committees, however, there are endless cutouts. They spawn front groups in numbers that rival days when the Soviet Communist Party nurtured "peace" committees.
The Affordable Housing Council is another Realtor group. Its latest filing shows $235,000 in donations, $195,285 in expenditures. A majority of the dough comes in two big gifts, $120,000 from the BIAW and $60,000 from the Olympia Master Builders.
Of the expenditures, $185,000 has gone to something called Progress for Our Community, which in turn has given $160,000 to People's Choice for Leadership. The revealing hint comes in a $38,000 allocation to Dresner Wickers & Assoc., a top Republican direct-mail outfit.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce used a front -- the Voters Education Committee -- to channel $1.5 million to smear ex-Insurance Commissioner Deborah Senn when she ran for attorney general in 2004.
The committee revealed its "donation" long after the election. The Chamber of Commerce refused to name its donors, saying the money was not specifically raised to fight Senn.
Homebuilders, contractors, and Realtors aren't just reactionary robots. They ought to demand accountability from those manipulating their money.
State Sen. Rodney Tom, D-Bellevue, himself in the real estate business, unloaded when I talked to him earlier this week.
"There's a huge disconnect between the Realtors Quality of Life PAC and the real estate agent out on the street," Tom said.
"They don't want their members to know how they're spending the money." http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/connelly/380283_Joel24.html
By JOEL CONNELLY P-I COLUMNIST
E-mail this Print this RSS
Last updated September 23, 2008 11:22 p.m. PT
Friday, September 19, 2008
PDC to Citizens - Washington Continues to Lead Nation in Campaign Finance Disclosure
The state’s campaign finance laws and program are administered by the Public Disclosure Commission, a five-member, bipartisan citizen commission that is appointed by the Governor and confirmed by the state Senate. Current members are Chair Ken Schellberg (Seabeck), Vice-Chair Jim Clements (Selah), Secretary Dave Seabrook (Battle Ground), and members Jane Noland (Seattle) and Bill Brumsickle (Centralia). No member may serve more than one five-year term.
The above press release was written by Lori Anderson - Washington State Public Disclosure Commission.
Call me a cynic - I would be thrilled for the state of Washington, but there are still several candidates who have not reported in-kind contributions received from the Realtors Quality of Life PAC for the 2007 election cycle.
In the PDC Report of Investigation on the Realtors, staff states that a PDC employee mistakenly told two local candidates that the in-kind donations, (as reported by the Realtors), were in fact, independent expenditures and that they did not have to report them.
*
But that error was acknowledged by the both the Realtors and the PDC around the 20th of October, so why didn't the PDC require the candidates who received in-kind contributions to report the receipt of the contributions before the General Election?
*
Here is a list of candidates who did not report in-kind contributions from the Realtor's Quality of Life PAC before the November 2007 General Election.None of the candidates on the list has filed an amended C-6 since the Realtors reported the in-kind expenditures on their amended PDC forms in the Spring of 2008.
*
Liz Aspen, 2007 Campaign for City Council of Woodinville (won her race for council)
Sam Crawford, 2007 Campaign for County Council of Whatcom County (won his race for council)
Liz S. Pike, 2007 Campaign for Mayor of Camas (lost her race for the mayor's seat)
Daniel V. Pike, 2007 Campaign for Mayor of Bellingham (won his race for the mayor's seat)
James Slowick, 2007 Campaign for Mayor of Oak Harbor (won his race for the mayor's seat)
Penny Sweet, 2007 Campaign for City Council of Kirkland (lost her race for council)
John Tarrant, 2007 Campaign for Mayor of Shelton (won his race for the mayor's seat)
Robert A.Van Schoorl, 2007 Campaign for Port Commissioner of Olympia (did not win his race for Port Cm) *
I wonder - would some of the voters have made a different choice, if they knew how much money some of the candidates received from the Realtors PAC?
*
Now, before you blame the Realtors, please note that a number of candidates from across the state reported in-kind contributions from the Realtors Quality of Life PAC before the General Election: (Granted, some of the candidates received the information late, but they did take the time to report the in-kinds on their reports before the General election.
*
Thumbs up to the candidates listed above.
*
The Realtor's Quality of Life PAC complaint is scheduled to be heard by the full PDC Commission on September 25, 2008.
Sadly, in the state of Washington, it appears that some candidates are above the law...
